Rockwall Denies Zipline Drone Hub, Tells Company To Come Back With A Flight Map

Rockwall City Hall & Decisions

Rockwall Denies Zipline Drone Hub, Tells Company To Come Back With A Flight Map

Rockwall City Council denied Zipline's drone delivery hub at Rockwall Crossing without prejudice on Nov. 2, asking the company to return with a flight map and a time-limited permit.

Interactive mode

See this story, step by step.

The same reporting, built as you scroll. Go at your own pace.

Rockwall Weekly

Rockwall City Council denied Zipline's request for a drone delivery hub at the Rockwall Crossing shopping center on Nov. 2, closing out a case that had stretched across three council meetings. The unanimous vote was "without prejudice," which means the company is free to apply again.

Mayor Tim McCallum, who made the motion, said the denial was meant to send Zipline back to finish what council had asked for. "When you come back, come back with a map," he told the company. "Come back with a limited SUP so that we do have some control."

Don’t miss what’s changing in Rockwall.

Get updates on new businesses, city decisions, development projects, and local spending. One clear email every Wednesday.

Free newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime.

Rockwall Says Yes To Rockwall District And No To Zipline Drones ↗

A hub tucked behind the shopping center

Zipline, which describes itself as the world's largest drone delivery company, asked for a specific use permit, a zoning approval that lets council allow a particular use on a property and attach conditions to it. The site is a vacant tract of about 2 acres inside Rockwall Crossing near I-30 and Ralph Hall Parkway, behind a pet store and next to a TxDOT storage yard. City staff said the plan called for four charging towers, each 26 and a half feet tall and holding 12 drones, inside a metal fence screened by trees and shrubs. Ryan Miller, the city's director of planning and zoning, said the nearest home is more than 600 feet from the facility.

Customers would order through Zipline's app, local businesses would fill the orders, and drones would fly out from the hub and return to charge. A company representative told council in October that the drones fly at about 300 feet and produce about 60 decibels, which the company compared to something between an air conditioner and a refrigerator.

The Planning and Zoning Commission recommended approval. Council tabled the case on Sept. 15 and again on Oct. 19, when McCallum asked Zipline to bring back a city map showing the area it would serve and the places drones would avoid, such as schools.

The map that didn't arrive

Zipline did not bring that map on Nov. 2. Its government affairs manager said the drones currently operate within about two and a half miles of a charging station, and that a fixed map wasn't practical because "with time that that radius may change."

"The map wasn't for you. The map was not for me. The map was for our citizens to see," McCallum replied. "So I'm a little disappointed we don't have it."

Councilmember Richard Henson asked whether Zipline would agree not to fly over Buffalo Creek, a largely city-owned green space along the south edge of the nearby Flagstone Creek neighborhood. The representative said the company could commit to that if council required it. Councilmember Melba Jeffus asked how many residents had toured Zipline's Rowlett hub, which council had delayed the vote to allow. "For our open house, there were no visitors from Rockwall," the representative said, adding that some people may have visited the site on their own.

Neighbors split on the noise

Most speakers at the public hearing lived in Flagstone Creek. Justin Hoppel said he visited the Rowlett hub and talked with people in the neighborhood behind it, and that nearly everyone told him "the drone noise is there all day, every day." He also warned council that the company's offers were not binding. "Those aren't commitments, and they can't be enforced once they're granted," he said.

Resident Bob Wacker urged approval, pointing to drone deliveries of defibrillators that he said some states now coordinate with fire and police departments.

Council members who visited Rowlett came away with different impressions. Councilmember Anna Campbell said the drones were "still loud" even with highway noise nearby. "At first, I wasn't too concerned about the noise, and now I am," she said. Councilmember Dennis Lewis said he and McCallum stood outside the fence, 10 to 15 feet from where drones were landing, and held a normal conversation. "We did not have to raise our voices," he said. Councilmember John Hagaman said he supports the technology but "would just love to see it in a different location."

Who controls the sky

Much of the debate came down to how much say Rockwall would have after an approval. Council was told it can regulate only what happens on the ground. "You can't regulate their flight patterns," a city official said. "That's the FAA's purview."

Jeffus said she started out "totally against" the hub, changed her mind after visiting Rowlett, and had turned against it again because Zipline did not bring what council asked for. She said residents with complaints would not call the company. "They're going to call us and complain," she said. "And then we really won't have any control over what's going on after we approve this."

Zipline offered to provide quarterly reports on resident complaints. "Our partners will hold us accountable. The community will hold us accountable. You will hold us accountable," the representative said.

Miller told council it could attach conditions to the permit, including a time limit. Those limits usually run one to two years and give council a chance to review how a use is operating, and council can remove a permit if problems arise. McCallum said he wanted a renewal requirement "so that we can say to the citizens, have they done their job?"

McCallum said he had spoken with Rowlett's mayor, who praised Zipline as a responsive partner and said he "would vote for it again tomorrow." Still, the mayor told the company, "I don't think you have the votes here."

Henson seconded the motion. Lewis said he would have preferred a straight up-or-down vote, but the denial passed unanimously, with Mayor Pro Tem Mark Moeller absent. Whether Zipline returns is now up to the company. As McCallum put it, the denial "gives you a chance to go back, do your homework, and come back, or decide not to come back."

Want the next one from Rockwall?

One email for Rockwall, every Wednesday. Free.

Send me the next one