Rockwall Business & Development
'Lipstick On A Pig': Rockwall Sends Back Luxury Garage Upgrade, And The Developer Pulls It
Garages of America withdrew its Horizon Road redesign after Rockwall City Council sent it back to P&Z 4-2 over a 600-unit self-storage building.
Interactive mode
See this story, step by step.
The same reporting, built as you scroll. Go at your own pace.
The developer behind Garages of America has withdrawn its plan to redesign a 13.54-acre project on Horizon Road, eight days after the Rockwall City Council sent it back to the Planning and Zoning Commission instead of voting on it.
Council voted 4-2 on Nov. 2 to send the case back over a two-story self-storage building at the front of the site. On Nov. 10, the commission accepted the applicant's request to withdraw it, 6-0 with one member absent. That leaves the zoning council approved in 2022 in place, a plan that council members on both sides of the vote called worse than the one they turned away.
The plan on the table
The triangle-shaped property sits on the north side of Horizon Road near Country Club Drive. In June 2022, council created Planned Development District 96 there to allow luxury garages and flex office and warehouse buildings. A planned development district is custom zoning with its own rules for a single property.
According to city planning staff, the site plans approved in 2022 and 2024 expired in August 2026 when the project's engineering plans expired. The zoning itself did not.
The new request split the land into three areas and cut the project from 13 buildings to seven:
- Area 1: a two-story, climate-controlled self-storage building with up to 600 units. City code allows 125 units per acre, or about 316 here, so the request was nearly double.
- Area 2: five buildings with up to 74 luxury garage units, sold like condominiums to car collectors. Owners can add lounges or small offices, but no one can live in them.
- Area 3: a future medical office or limited commercial building of up to 45 feet.
The redesign dropped the flex office and warehouse buildings, which the company's representative described as metal panel buildings next to future homes. It also doubled the landscape buffer facing the neighboring residential land to 20 feet and added a berm and three tiers of screening. City planning staff told council the commission had recommended approval 6-0 on Oct. 27, and that the city received no responses to 18 notices mailed to nearby property owners.
'I'm out on the self-storage'
The new buildings won praise. The objection was what would be inside the one at the front.
"I would love to pull those out of the ground tomorrow," Council Member John Hagaman said. He also called the approved buildings "atrocious." But he said he was "just out on the mini storage," adding that he did not think it was what the golf course community across the street and future neighbors were looking for. "If you wanted to take that and replace it with more garages, all day long," he said.
Mayor Tim McCallum said he lives off Horizon Road and drives it every day. He said that during annexations in the early 2000s, when he was on the council, some landowners poured slabs between readings of the ordinance to get grandfathered in, and later councils allowed commercial zoning along the road.
"If we're going to try to put lipstick on a pig, let's do that," McCallum said, suggesting the storage be moved out of sight and the front be used for retail or medical offices. Of a self-storage sign on the road, he said, "It's going to be ugly. And I'm going to have to pass by it every day."
Council Member Richard Henson asked whether the company would consider retail in the front building. The company's representative said his investors wanted to move forward with the approved project if the city turned them down. He said he would talk to them, but added, "I have a feeling it's going to be no."
'They can do it by right'
Council Member Dennis Lewis argued for voting that night. "This is way better than what we've got," he said. "You could start what you've got approved tomorrow."
"We're going to end up with something way worse than this," Lewis warned. "And they can do it by right." McCallum answered, "That won't be on my conscience. I didn't vote for it."
McCallum made the motion to send the case back to the commission, and Hagaman seconded it. It passed 4-2, with Lewis voting no. The recording does not show who cast the other no vote. The representative asked what would happen if the investors simply said no. McCallum told him to work that out with staff.
Eight days later, the case came back to the commission as a withdrawal. The commission approved the request without discussion. The applicant has not said publicly what it plans to build on the site.
Want the next one from Rockwall?
One email for Rockwall, every Wednesday. Free.
Send me the next one




